Protein

Protein is where longevity advice contradicts itself most. Animal studies say eat less to live longer, while muscle science says midlife and older adults need more, not less. Both sides have a point. The human data are messier than either camp admits, and the answer is mostly about how you eat protein, not cutting it.

Eat roughly 0.8–1.2 g of protein per kg of body weight a day if you are sedentary, 1.2–1.6 g if you train, and 1.0–1.5 g past 65. Spread it as about 0.4 g/kg per meal (25–30 g for most adults), and draw it mostly from fish, legumes, dairy, eggs, poultry and soy rather than red and processed meat. Lift weights too; that is what turns protein into muscle. Past 55, don't sit above about 1.8 g/kg year after year without a specific reason.

Why the same nutrient gets opposite advice

Protein switches on the body's main growth signal, a sensor called mTOR whose strongest trigger is the amino acid leucine. That builds muscle, but kept on all day it switches off the cell's cleanup program and may feed artery plaque. One influential theory treats chronic mTOR activity as a central driver of ageing.[1] Neither extreme is healthy: constant growth signalling is linked to atherosclerosis and cancer, constant breakdown to frailty and muscle loss. More under deregulated nutrient sensing.

Two numbers: where muscle stops gaining and arteries may start losing

About 0.4 g/kg of protein per meal gets most of the muscle-building response; much more at every meal is where a plausible cardiovascular cost begins.

The "muscle full" dose. In older men, muscle building from one meal plateaued at about 0.4 g of high-quality protein per kg of body weight, roughly 25–30 g for an average adult. Young men plateaued at about 0.24 g/kg, so 0.4 g/kg is a generous target at any age.[2] That is an efficiency point, not a ceiling: in young men, 100 g of protein after exercise drove more muscle building, for longer, than 25 g, so protein above it is used more slowly, not wasted.[3]

The artery threshold. The muscle-full dose sits close to the dose that switches on mTOR in macrophages, the immune cells that clear fat from artery walls: more than about 25 g of protein per meal, or more than about 22% of calories as protein day in day out.[4] Extra leucine enlarged plaques in male mice bred to develop atherosclerosis, but the human groups were 14 and 9 people and the measure was a blood signalling marker, not plaque or heart attacks; the limits are on Leucine. It makes "more is better" wrong without making "less is better" right.

Does more protein help or hurt your lifespan?

In the biggest studies, more protein (especially plant protein) tracks with slightly lower death rates and healthier ageing; the alarming findings come from single analyses that disagree on age. All of this is observational.

The famous alarm. In about 6,400 adults from a US national nutrition survey, high protein intake at ages 50–65 was associated with about four times the cancer mortality and 75% higher overall mortality, driven by animal protein. Above 65 the pattern flipped and high protein looked protective, except for a rise in diabetes deaths at every age.[5] But it rests on one day of remembered diet, the overall-mortality result only just reached significance, and much larger analyses find no such flip.

The bigger picture favours protein, especially plant protein. Pooling 32 cohorts, over 715,000 people and 113,039 deaths, higher protein intake went with slightly lower overall mortality. Each extra 3% of calories from plant protein tracked with about 5% lower mortality.[6] The apparent harm of animal protein concentrates in red and processed meat and in people with other lifestyle risks; in two large US cohorts, swapping 3% of calories from processed red meat to plant protein went with 34% lower mortality.[7]

On healthy ageing, every protein source looks good. In 48,762 women followed for three decades from before age 60, more protein of every kind went with better odds of reaching old age free of eleven chronic diseases and with mind and body intact. Per 3% of calories, the odds rose about 5% for total protein, 7% for animal, 14% for dairy and 38% for plant protein.[8] Only 7.6% met this demanding bar; it is the strongest sign that the plant advantage is about what comes with the protein, not about eating less of it.

But very high habitual intake has a warning sign. In 19,420 UK Biobank participants followed for up to 16 years, people eating 1.8 g/kg a day or more had about 21% more major cardiovascular events, 39% higher overall mortality and 73% higher cardiovascular death. The extra risk of major cardiovascular events sat in the over-55s, the opposite age pattern to the US survey.[9] The cohort was nearly three-quarters women with a median age of 54, so the younger group's clean result is imprecise, and such high intakes travel with other habits. Still, it is the one human outcome signal behind the mechanism.

It is probably not about IGF-1. Animal protein is assumed to raise the growth hormone IGF-1 more than plant protein, but in one small six-week trial of 37 adults with type 2 diabetes, both raised it by about 14%.[10] If that holds, the plant advantage more likely comes from lower methionine and leucine, the surrounding food, and the carcinogens in red and processed meat.

What protein replaces matters. In mice with a DNA-repair defect that speeds up ageing, a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet shortened lifespan by 18% in males and 36% in females, while low-protein, high-carbohydrate diets did not.[11] A fragile mouse model, but it suggests protein at the expense of carbohydrate, especially if sedentary, is not the longevity diet.

How much you need, and why it rises with age

The official minimum is a floor against deficiency, not a target. Training adults benefit up to about 1.6 g/kg a day, and older adults probably need 1.0–1.2 g/kg or more.

The official minimum is low. The official recommended intake is 0.8 g/kg (the WHO's equivalent is 0.83). A newer measuring method put the recommended intake at 1.2 g/kg, about 50% above the standard figure, though in only eight young men.[12] In men over 65 it also landed above the official number,[13] though critics argue the method measures maximal muscle building rather than a true minimum.

Older muscle needs more. Ageing muscle responds less to the same protein ("anabolic resistance"), and measured directly in adults over 60, the daily leucine requirement was more than twice the current recommendation.[14]

Expert consensus for older adults. The international PROT-AGE group recommends 1.0–1.2 g/kg a day for healthy older adults, 1.2–1.5 g/kg with acute or chronic illness, and up to 2.0 g/kg in severe illness, injury or malnutrition.[15][16] The European clinical nutrition society (ESPEN) reached the same numbers independently.[17]

For people who train. Pooling 49 studies and 1,863 people, gains in muscle from protein supplements levelled off at about 1.6 g/kg a day, though the plausible range around that figure is wide (1.03–2.20).[18] The International Society of Sports Nutrition puts the exercising range at 1.4–2.0 g/kg, and 2.3–3.1 g/kg for trained lifters dieting to keep muscle.[19] That top figure is a short-term tool for a dieting lifter, not a way to eat for years.

Protein plus lifting rebuilds older muscle. Pooling 10 trials in 1,154 older adults, whey protein increased limb muscle mass against placebo, and whey combined with resistance training increased grip strength; the two results come from different comparisons.[20] Across 78 trials, whey ranked first of all protein sources for muscle mass, grip strength and walking speed.[21]

What to actually eat, day to day

Hit a daily total that fits your age and training, split it into meals of about 0.4 g/kg, and treat anything near 2 g/kg as a temporary setting.

Daily total

WhoDaily proteinPer meal
Sedentary midlife adult0.8–1.2 g/kg25–30 g across 3 meals
Active midlife adult1.2–1.6 g/kg25–40 g, with a dose around training
Older adult (65 and over)1.0–1.5 g/kg~0.4 g/kg: 25–30 g at 65–75 kg, 30–40 g above that
Hypertrophy phase, hard training past 65, a calorie deficit, or recovery from acute illness or surgery1.6–2.0 g/kg, for the phase onlydistributed; follow clinical advice when ill

For a 75 kg person, the active-midlife target means 90–120 g a day; older adults who exercise should aim for at least 1.2 g/kg.[22]

On a GLP-1 drug such as semaglutide, base the target on fat-free mass or an absolute 80–120 g a day rather than total body weight, avoid sustained intake at or above 2 g/kg, and keep lifting; the four-society advisory behind those numbers is covered under Ozempic-class drugs.

Per meal

Split the total into meals of about 0.4 g/kg; three of them make about 1.2 g/kg a day. Spreading protein evenly is a reasonable habit, not a settled fact: it rests mostly on one trial of eight people, two of whose authors were paid speakers for a beef industry association,[23] and a later trial in older adults found no difference between even and skewed patterns.[24] A 40 g protein feed before bed raised overnight muscle building in older men where 20 g did nothing;[25] it helps only if it adds to your daily total, and a long-term benefit in older adults is not yet shown. The per-meal, bedtime and around-training trials are weighed on Protein timing.

Don't routinely go far past 0.4 g/kg at several meals a day unless you are training around it. A 250–300 g steak carries 60–80 g of protein, well past efficient muscle building and into the range that pushes blood leucine toward the artery threshold.

Eating windows and low-protein days

A daily eating window is meant to restore the swing between building and recycling, though its cleanup benefits are established mostly in animals; the evidence is under Fasting and time-restricted eating. Some people add one or two low-protein days a week, under about 0.8 g/kg, to let blood leucine fall while lifting holds muscle. No human trial has tested this; it is extrapolated from the biology above.

Which protein: plant, fish and dairy over red meat

The case against red and processed meat runs through its amino-acid make-up and the cancer risk from processing. Fish and fermented dairy have the most consistently good record.

Methionine. This amino acid is concentrated in meat, poultry, eggs and dairy and scarcer in legumes. Restricting it extends lifespan in yeast, worms, flies and rodents, but no primate has been tested, so applying this to humans is an inference, not a finding.[26]

Colorectal cancer. Each 50 g a day of processed meat is linked to an 18% higher risk of colorectal cancer, and each 100 g a day of unprocessed red meat to about 17% higher.[27] The WHO cancer agency classes processed meat as carcinogenic to humans and red meat as probably carcinogenic. See Foods to limit.

Sources differ. Among measured protein isolates, whey is one of the richest in leucine (about 2.7 g per 25 g of protein), while soy and pea carry far less methionine than animal proteins;[28] collagen is poor for muscle but rich in glycine (below).

Fish, eggs, yogurt and poultry differ from red meat, which is what most of the cohorts behind "animal protein is bad" measured, though they are not spotless. Across 33 cohorts and 2.2 million people, the highest egg intakes carried no higher overall mortality than the lowest, but each extra egg a week tracked with about 2% higher overall and 4% higher cancer mortality,[29] and a single Italian cohort found more than 300 g of poultry a week linked to higher mortality than under 100 g.[30]

Plant protein works for muscle if you eat enough. On formal quality scores many plant isolates rate below the best animal proteins,[31] but the gap mostly disappears once quantity is matched. Vegans and meat-eaters eating about 1.6 g/kg gained similar muscle size and strength over 12 weeks of lifting.[32] A plant blend came close to milk protein in 24 people, though milk raised blood essential amino acids about twice as much.[33] These samples were small and mostly young; in older adults, a meat-containing meal can beat a vegan one with the same protein, so older plant eaters should eat more and lean on blends.

Glycine: a cheap buffer for meat eaters

Glycine, abundant in collagen, gelatin and bone broth and scarce in muscle meat, helps the liver mop up excess methionine, and a glycine-rich diet slightly extended lifespan in mice of both sexes at three independent sites.[34] If your protein is meat-heavy, eat the connective tissue too or take 5–10 g of plain glycine a day. No human trial has tested this against any health outcome; it is a cheap, safe bet.

Protein and training

Protein most clearly buys muscle around lifting; exact timing, and the order of cardio and weights, matter much less than claimed.

Pooling 21 trials, 20–40 g of whey around a resistance session raised muscle building;[35] a normal protein-containing meal works fine. The window is hours, not the old "30 minutes": in the five trials that compared protein before versus after each session for at least four weeks, neither timing won, on thin evidence.[36]

Mixing cardio and weights. Separating fasted cardio from fed lifting is a tidy idea, not a proven advantage; combined training builds muscle as well as lifting alone (see Resistance training).

BCAA supplements (leucine, isoleucine and valine) are worse than whole protein: they trip the growth signal without the other essential amino acids muscle needs, as explained under Leucine.[37]

Weight loss, bone and frailty

Protein matters most when calories are cut, it helps bone, and the one caution is for people already frail.

Weight loss. Higher-protein diets during calorie restriction keep more lean mass and shed more fat. In 24 pooled trials in 1,063 people, everyone's resting metabolism slowed, but the higher-protein groups lost about 140 kcal a day less of it, though the plausible range is wide (roughly 16 to 269).[38] In older adults, at least 1.0 g/kg a day during weight loss retained more lean mass.[39] Protein is also the most filling nutrient, and about a quarter of its energy goes on digesting it, which adds to its value on a diet or a GLP-1 drug.

Bone. The idea that protein's acid load leaches calcium from bone has not held up: a systematic review found protein above the official minimum is not harmful and modestly protects spine bone density[40] (the review was funded by an osteoporosis charity). The fracture evidence and how protein fits with calcium and training are under Bone density.

Frailty. Among 1,868 older adults who already had two or more chronic conditions, those eating the most protein were about a third less likely to become frail than those eating the least. But among those who had already become frail, higher protein tracked with higher mortality, on only 83 deaths.[41] Protein may help prevent frailty without rescuing it; everyone here was already ill, so this says nothing about healthy older adults.

Who should be careful

  • Chronic kidney disease. Current kidney guidelines suggest about 0.8 g/kg a day in stages 3–5 and, at any stage, avoiding more than 1.3 g/kg if the disease is at risk of progressing; older people who are frail or losing muscle may need more — agree it with your kidney team.[42] PROT-AGE also excludes people whose kidney filtration rate is below 30 mL/min/1.73 m² and who are not on dialysis; they may need less protein, not more.[43]
  • Over 55 with a very high habitual intake. Outside the temporary situations above, don't sit at 1.8 g/kg a day or more year after year; in the one cohort that tested it, that intake tracked with more cardiovascular events and deaths overall, and the extra cardiovascular events were concentrated in the over-55s.
  • On a GLP-1 drug. Avoid sustained intake at 2 g/kg a day or more; base targets on fat-free mass or 80–120 g, not total body weight.
  • Already frail, with several chronic conditions. In one cohort of older adults who were already ill and frail, higher protein tracked with higher mortality; decide your intake with a clinician (see frailty above).
  • Red and processed meat. Keep unprocessed red meat to at most about three servings a week (350–500 g cooked), fewer with a family history of colorectal cancer or cardiovascular disease, and limit processed meat aggressively: the WHO cancer agency classes it as carcinogenic to humans.

What's overrated, and what's wrong

  • "Animal protein is bad" as a blanket claim. Fish and fermented dairy have consistently good data; eggs and poultry are mixed but far from red meat.
  • "Protein damages kidneys." Only in pre-existing kidney disease. Pooling 28 trials in healthy people, the change in kidney filtration on high-protein diets did not differ from controls, though the senior author has received dairy and beef industry funding.[44]
  • "Just eat less protein." People eat to a roughly fixed daily protein target, so on a protein-dilute diet they eat more calories to reach it.[45] A pre-registered analysis of 11,152 adults confirmed the calorie effect but could not test body weight, and the link to obesity is contested.[46] Amid ultra-processed food, cutting protein blindly risks eating more calories, not less protein.

Further reading

  • Levine ME et al. Low Protein Intake Is Associated with a Major Reduction in IGF-1, Cancer, and Overall Mortality in the 65 and Younger but Not Older Population. Cell Metab 2014.[47]
  • Naghshi S et al. Dietary intake of total, animal, and plant proteins and risk of all cause, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality: systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. BMJ 2020;370:m2412.[48]
  • Ardisson Korat AV et al. Dietary protein intake in midlife in relation to healthy aging — results from the prospective Nurses' Health Study cohort. Am J Clin Nutr 2024;119(2):271–282.[49]
  • Zhang X et al. Identification of a leucine-mediated threshold effect governing macrophage mTOR signalling and cardiovascular risk. Nature Metabolism 2024;6(2):359–377.[50]
  • Moore DR et al. Protein ingestion to stimulate myofibrillar protein synthesis requires greater relative protein intakes in healthy older versus younger men. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2015.[51]
  • Trommelen J et al. The anabolic response to protein ingestion during recovery from exercise has no upper limit in magnitude and duration in vivo in humans. Cell Rep Med 2023;4(12):101324.[52]
  • Morton RW et al. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adults. Br J Sports Med 2018.[53]
  • Bauer J et al. Evidence-based recommendations for optimal dietary protein intake in older people: a position paper from the PROT-AGE Study Group. J Am Med Dir Assoc 2013.[54]
  • Hevia-Larraín V et al. High-protein plant-based diet versus a protein-matched omnivorous diet to support resistance training adaptations. Sports Med 2021.[55]
  • Bouvard V et al. Carcinogenicity of consumption of red and processed meat. Lancet Oncol 2015 (IARC).[56]
  • Miller RA et al. Glycine supplementation extends lifespan of male and female mice. Aging Cell 2019.[57]
  • Devries MC et al. Changes in kidney function do not differ between healthy adults consuming higher- compared with lower- or normal-protein diets: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Nutr 2018.[58]
  • Wolfe RR. Branched-chain amino acids and muscle protein synthesis in humans: myth or reality? J Int Soc Sports Nutr 2017.[59]
  • Raubenheimer D, Simpson SJ. Protein appetite as an integrator in the obesity system: the protein leverage hypothesis. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2023.[60]

— § —