Sweeteners

Added sugar deserves its bad reputation, and the fructose half of it is what makes it metabolically different — in large amounts it pushes the liver to build fat. But the same fructose eaten in whole fruit is far less of a problem, and which sugar you eat (table sugar, corn syrup, honey) matters much less than how much, in what form, and how fast.

Cut sugary drinks and fruit juice first — they are the biggest source and carry the clearest risks — then keep added sugar under about 25 g a day for women and 36 g for men, and avoid taking it in one big hit. Drink water, coffee or tea by default, eat fruit whole, and treat honey as sugar with extras rather than a health food. For calorie-free options, see Sugar substitutes — and note that the sugar alcohols erythritol and xylitol carry a cardiovascular caution.

Sugary drinks and juice are the biggest lever

Drinks are the largest single source of added sugar in most diets, and they carry the clearest risks. In pooled cohort studies, people drinking the most sugar-sweetened drinks had about 27% more type 2 diabetes, 17% more coronary heart disease and 11% higher death rates than those drinking the least, with risk climbing steadily as intake rose.[1] These are observational studies, but they are among the most replicated signals in nutrition. See foods to limit or avoid for the wider picture.

Juice is not the safe swap. It keeps the sugar and loses most of the fibre, and on deaths from any cause it does at least as badly: the same pooled data put juice at about 26% higher all-cause mortality, against 11% for sugary drinks, though only two cohorts fed the juice figure and juice was not linked to diabetes there.[2] A larger Harvard analysis found no mortality link for juice, so treat the 26% as a warning, not a measurement.[3] In one US cohort of 13,440 people, each daily 355 mL glass of juice went with about 24% higher mortality, where soft drinks alone did not reach significance.[4]

Why fructose is different from glucose

Table sugar is half glucose, half fructose, and both carry 4 kcal per gram — but the liver handles them differently. Glucose has a built-in brake: when a liver cell already has plenty of energy, an enzyme early in the pathway slows further breakdown. Fructose has no such brake; it is processed as fast as it arrives, whether the cell needs the energy or not.[5]

That rush briefly drains the cell's energy currency (ATP) and generates uric acid inside the cell. The uric acid stresses the mitochondria — the cell's power plants — and partly jams the routes that burn fuel, so the incoming carbons are diverted into making new fat. Some stays in the liver, the root of fatty liver disease; the rest goes into the blood as triglycerides.[6] The same pathway also damps two of the cell's master nutrient sensors, SIRT1 and AMPK, which govern cellular clean-up and mitochondrial upkeep.[7]

Controlled trials back this up, with a limit. In a 7-week randomised trial, drinks sweetened with fructose or table sugar roughly doubled the liver's basic rate of fat-making, while glucose drinks did not.[8] Blood triglycerides rise too, but at high loads: getting 30% of energy from fructose produced severely raised triglycerides in a small crossover trial.[9] And the liver damage is about extra calories: pooling 51 controlled trials in 2,059 people, liver fat and a liver-damage marker rose only when the sugars were added on top of the diet, not when they replaced other carbohydrates calorie for calorie.[10]

Why the pathway exists at all is a matter of debate. Our ape ancestors lost the enzyme that breaks down uric acid millions of years ago, which amplified the response to fructose. One group argues this was a survival programme — eat more, store fat — before seasonal scarcity, now running all year round in a world of cheap sugar.[11] Other obesity researchers have disputed this "fructose survival hypothesis" in print.[12]

Fructose is not poison at every dose. The clearest harms in feeding studies, extra liver fat and high triglycerides, come from large doses, mostly in drinks and on top of the usual diet. Small amounts — around 10 g of fructose a meal, up to about 36 g a day in the trials — may help the liver clear glucose by freeing a key glucose-handling enzyme. A 2012 pooling of six small feeding trials in 118 people found such doses, swapped for other carbohydrates, lowered long-term blood sugar (HbA1c) by about 0.4 percentage points without harming weight, lipids or uric acid. The analysis is small, has not been confirmed since, and its lead author discloses grants from The Coca-Cola Company.[13] That enzyme-freeing effect of small doses may help explain why the fructose in berries and vegetables seems well tolerated.

Sugar and biological ageing: an interesting signal, not a verdict

The ageing link rests on three observational snapshots, none of which can show cause.

Epigenetic clocks. In 342 midlife Black and White women, each extra gram of added sugar a day tracked with a slightly older reading — about 0.02 years — on the GrimAge2 clock, a DNA-methylation measure of biological age. Average intake was about 61 g a day, above the 50 g Daily Value the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) uses on food labels, which is a labelling reference rather than a recommendation. The study measured people at one point in time, its authors describe the added-sugar estimates as "close to zero, suggesting a smaller role for added sugar compared with healthy dietary measures", and they call for longer-term studies.[14]

Telomeres from soda. A US national survey found regular sugary-soda drinking linked to shorter telomeres, equivalent to about 4.6 years of extra cellular ageing at a daily 590 mL serving. Diet soda and non-fizzy sugary drinks showed nothing, and 100% juice leaned slightly the other way on a result the authors call weakened by confounders.[15]

Telomeres from fructose. In 282 healthy Lebanese adults, those eating the most fructose were about three times as likely, and those eating the most added fructose about twice as likely, to have middle-length rather than the longest telomeres. The authors found no dose-response and flag their small sample themselves.[16]

The fat-building pathway above makes these findings plausible, but whether added sugar moves any individual's biological age is unknown. The stronger reason to cut sugary drinks remains the mortality data.

Fruit is not the problem; juice is

The fructose in an apple is the same molecule as in a soft drink, but the outcome differs because intact plant cell walls slow its release, so it reaches the liver gradually instead of in a flood. Fibre that reaches the colon is also fermented by gut bacteria into short-chain fatty acids; two of them, butyrate and propionate, change how genes are packaged and switched on in cells.[17]

In pooled cohort data, every 80 g of whole fruit a day went with about 6% lower cardiovascular mortality, in the same analysis where sugary drinks went the other way.[18] A 2025 review urges caution about counting 100% juice as a whole-fruit serving, particularly for children.[19] Smoothies, which keep the fibre, looked more like whole fruit than juice in one cross-sectional survey of 443 people — suggestive, not settled.[20] Blended is not the same as juiced.

Among fruits, the ratio of fructose to fibre is a better guide than total sugar (typical servings; values vary by variety):

FoodFructoseFibreNotes
Avocado (1 medium, ~150 g flesh)<1 g~9 gTrace fructose
Raspberries (1 cup)~3 g~8 g
Blackberries (1 cup)~3.5 g~7.5 g
Strawberries (1 cup)~3.8 g~3 g
Mango (½ medium, ~110 g)~5 g~1.7 gA whole large mango is ~16 g
Apple (1 medium)~9.5 g~4.4 g
Watermelon (large wedge, 286 g)~10 g~1.1 gLow fibre
Grapes (1 cup)~12 g~1.4 gLow fibre
Dried figs (1 cup, 149 g)~34 g~14.5 gDrying concentrates sugar; treat as dessert

None of this means avoiding mangoes. Make berries and other high-fibre fruit the default, and treat grapes and dried fruit as occasional. For meal sequencing and blood-sugar spikes, see glycemic index and postprandial glucose.

How much is too much

The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends keeping free sugars below 10% of daily energy, a strong recommendation; going below 5% is only a conditional suggestion on very weak evidence.[21] The American Heart Association sets at most 25 g a day for women and 36 g for men.[22] WHO's "free sugars" also count the natural sugar in 100% fruit juice; US "added sugars" do not.

The 2025–2030 US Dietary Guidelines dropped the daily percentage ceiling entirely. They say no amount of added sugar is recommended and that "one meal should contain no more than 10 grams of added sugars".[23] The document gives no reason for that figure. This site reads it as fitting the biology above — one large dose overwhelms the liver's fructose handling — but that is our inference, not the guideline's. The two approaches combine sensibly: cap the daily total, and spread it out rather than taking it in one go.

Timing, exercise, salt and water

Exercise. Fructose probably builds fat mainly when the liver's glycogen store is already full. In a crossover trial of eight healthy young men, a diet with 30% of energy from fructose raised triglycerides and liver fat-making when they were sedentary, and did neither when the same diet was paired with moderate aerobic exercise.[24] Moving before or after a carbohydrate-heavy meal is a sensible habit on that basis — an extrapolation, since the trial did not test timing around meals.

For endurance athletes, fructose is fuel. The gut's main glucose transporter tops out at around 60 g an hour; mixing glucose and fructose, typically 2:1, uses a separate fructose route and supports carbohydrate burning of about 90–105 g an hour, with less gut distress than glucose alone.[25]

Timing. Eating carbohydrates earlier in the day is reasonable but thinly evidenced. In a randomised crossover trial in just twelve healthy young adults, eating dinner one hour later worsened the blood-sugar response,[26] and in cohort data, habitually eating close to bedtime went with roughly twice the rate of fatty liver.[27]

Salt and water. The body can also make fructose from glucose, through a route called the polyol pathway, switched on by high blood sugar and, in animal studies, by a concentrated bloodstream from salt or dehydration. In mice, high-salt diets did exactly this and drove liver fat and resistance to leptin, an appetite hormone, without dietary sugar; the thirst hormone vasopressin appears to reinforce it. In the same paper, a separate observational study of 13,070 adults found that eating more than 11 g of salt a day went with about a third more diabetes and more fatty liver (22.3% against 15.5%).[28] In people, the evidence stops short: in a 44-person trial, drinking water with a salt or fructose load blunted the short-term rise in blood pressure, uric acid and the hormones renin and cortisol, but it measured neither vasopressin nor liver fat.[29] Whether more water reduces internal fructose production or liver fat has not been tested. Cutting salt and staying hydrated are cheap, low-risk bets — not proven fixes.

Corn syrup, honey and "better" sugars

High-fructose corn syrup is not uniquely toxic. The soft-drink form is about 55% fructose to 45% glucose, close to table sugar's even split, and both deliver similar amounts of fructose to the liver. Pooled trials (767 people in all) found a weight difference of just 0.29 kg between the two and no difference in waist, body-mass index, lipids or blood pressure, though waist size rests on only two trials. The one signal was a small rise in C-reactive protein, an inflammation marker, with corn syrup.[30] Cut the total, whichever syrup it comes in.

"Chicory syrup" can be the same thing in disguise. Some are mostly fibre, but others are made by breaking chicory inulin down into a syrup whose solids can be around 85% fructose, which is more fructose-heavy than corn syrup. If the label shows mostly sugars and little fibre, count it as sugar. Both kinds are covered under Chicory syrup.

Honey is sugar with extras. It is about 80% sugar, plus a small fraction of plant compounds. Pooling 18 trials in 1,105 people, eating around 40 g a day for about eight weeks lowered fasting glucose and total cholesterol slightly — both at low certainty. The same review found two inflammation markers rose, graded at a higher certainty than either benefit, and the glucose effect halved and lost significance once corrected for publication bias; two of its authors have had research support from the US National Honey Board, though the review itself was publicly funded.[31] In a three-way head-to-head trial, honey, table sugar and high-fructose corn syrup behaved alike over two weeks.[32] Whether heat-processed supermarket honey does any worse than raw has not been tested directly, and the anti-ageing claims for manuka honey and for honey's polyphenols rest on test-tube and animal work.

A tablespoon (about 20 g) of raw honey now and then is fine and probably slightly better than the same amount of refined sugar. Never give honey, raw or processed, to a baby under 12 months: it is the one identified dietary source of infant botulism.

Further reading

  • Li X et al. High-fructose corn syrup versus sucrose: a systematic review and meta-analysis of cardiometabolic effects. Frontiers in Nutrition 2022.[33]
  • Johnson RJ et al. Fructose: metabolic signal and modern hazard. Nature Metabolism 2026.[34]
  • Johnson RJ et al. The fructose survival hypothesis for obesity. Phil Trans R Soc B 2023.[35]
  • Ahmed A et al. Effect of honey on cardiometabolic risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Nutrition Reviews 2023.[36]
  • Egli L et al. Exercise prevents fructose-induced hypertriglyceridemia in healthy young subjects. Diabetes 2013.[37]
  • Lanaspa MA et al. High-salt intake causes leptin resistance and obesity in mice by stimulating endogenous fructose production and metabolism. PNAS 2018.[38]
  • Sievenpiper JL et al. "Catalytic" doses of fructose may benefit glycaemic control without harming cardiometabolic risk factors (meta-analysis). 2012.[39]
  • Chiu DT et al. Essential nutrients, added sugar intake, and epigenetic age in midlife Black and White women (NIMHD Social Epigenomics Program). JAMA Network Open 2024.[40]
  • Leung CW et al. Soda and cell aging: sugar-sweetened beverage consumption and leukocyte telomere length in healthy adults. Am J Public Health 2014.[41]
  • Messerlian N et al. Fructose intake and its association with relative telomere length: an exploratory study among healthy Lebanese adults. Frontiers in Nutrition 2023.[42]
  • Pase MP et al. Sugar- and artificially sweetened beverages and the risks of incident stroke and dementia. Stroke 2017.[43]
  • US Department of Health and Human Services and US Department of Agriculture. Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025–2030.[44]

— § —