Dietary fats

The "low-fat" decades produced a lot of confused eating and little measurable heart benefit. What replaced them is more useful: the type of fat matters more than the amount, what you put in place of a fat you cut largely decides whether cutting it helps, and the food a fat arrives in changes how it behaves.

Cut out industrial trans fats completely. Keep saturated fat to roughly a tenth of your calories, and when you cut it, replace it with vegetable oils, olive oil and nuts rather than bread and sugar. Use extra-virgin olive oil as your everyday oil, eat fatty fish twice a week, don't fear ordinary seed oils in your own kitchen, and treat up to about one egg a day as fine.

Why "how much fat" turned out to be the wrong question

The trials that tested eating less fat came up empty. The biggest, the Women's Health Initiative, randomly assigned 48,835 postmenopausal women to a low-fat eating pattern or their usual diet, and after about eight years found no reduction in heart disease, stroke or cardiovascular disease overall.[1]

That flat result needs two footnotes. The low-fat group never got near its target — fat intake fell by about 8 percentage points of calories, not the 15 or so the design assumed — so it tested a moderate cut, not a low-fat diet. And a later look found that women who entered the trial without heart disease or high blood pressure had about 30% less coronary heart disease during the trial, partly offset by more ischaemic strokes; the authors judged the result in the 3.4% who entered with established heart disease uninterpretable, because of later cholesterol-drug use.[2] Those subgroups were not planned in advance and the gap faded after the trial ended, so they are a reason to hold the null loosely, not to overturn it.

A huge observational study across many countries pointed the same way: higher total fat tracked with lower death rates, and very high carbohydrate intake with higher ones.[3] But it was observational, much of its carbohydrate signal came from low-income subsistence populations, and it drew heavy methodological criticism. Neither study says fat is good for you, only that amount is not where the action is.

Trans fats: the one fat to cut out completely

Industrial trans fats, made by partially hydrogenating vegetable oil, are the most harmful dietary fat known. Pooling 19 long-running cohorts and more than a million people, every extra 1% of calories from trans fat tracked with about 6% higher death rates, both overall and from cardiovascular disease.[4] Observational and modest, but the biology agrees: trans fats push "bad" LDL cholesterol up and "good" HDL cholesterol down at the same time, and higher intake goes with markedly higher levels of inflammation markers in the blood.[5]

The good news is that bans work. Between 1990 and 2021, the death rate attributed to high trans-fat intake among adults aged 55 and over fell by about 69%, driven by bans in wealthy countries,[6] though more than 4 billion people still lived without strong trans-fat rules in 2023.[7] Where the bans stand, and how to spot trans fat on a label, is under Trans fats.

The small amount of trans fat that occurs naturally in dairy and meat is a different molecule with a different record. A 2026 review of 10 trials and 12 cohorts found no effect on blood fats and no link to heart disease or type 2 diabetes at normal intakes.[8]

Saturated fat: what you swap it for decides the result

Cutting saturated fat does modestly reduce heart attacks and strokes — but how much depends almost entirely on what replaces it.

The best randomised evidence is a Cochrane review of 15 trials. In the 12 trials and nearly 54,000 people that measured it, cutting saturated fat for at least two years reduced cardiovascular events by about 17%, but made little or no difference to deaths, from heart disease or anything else.[9] The bigger the drop in saturated fat and blood cholesterol, the bigger the benefit (LDL cholesterol and its relatives are the main route from saturated fat to the heart), and it came mainly from trials that replaced saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat or starchy foods. A smaller 2025 analysis of 9 trials, mostly in people who already had heart disease, likewise found essentially no effect on deaths; it did not report combined events.[10]

What the replacement is makes the sharpest difference:

Swap saturated fat for…Effect on heart disease
Polyunsaturated fat (most vegetable oils, nuts, fish)About 30% lower risk — similar to a statin in people without heart disease
Monounsaturated fat (olive oil)Probably helpful, but the least certain of the good swaps
Refined carbohydrates and added sugarNo benefit — insulin resistance and blood fats get worse

The polyunsaturated and refined-carbohydrate rows are the core of the American Heart Association's 2017 advisory on dietary fat.[11] Two large US cohorts followed for decades put rough numbers on a small swap: moving 5% of calories from saturated fat to polyunsaturated fat tracked with about 25% lower coronary risk, to monounsaturated fat about 15%, and to whole-grain carbohydrate about 9%.[12] The WHO makes swapping to polyunsaturated fat a strong recommendation and swapping to plant monounsaturated fat only a conditional one.[13] In randomised trials comparing the two, though, polyunsaturated beat monounsaturated on LDL cholesterol by only a small margin.[14]

In a large 2025 study of 221,054 adults followed for up to 33 years, the people who ate the most butter had 15% higher death rates, those who ate the most plant oil had 16% lower, and swapping about 10 g a day of butter for plant oils was linked to about 17% lower overall and cancer death rates.[15] The butter eaters also smoked more and moved less, so this is observational support, not proof — but it points the same way as the trials.

Dairy versus red meat: the food matters, not just the molecule

Not all saturated fat seems to behave the same, though the evidence is thinner than the confident version of this claim suggests.

For yogurt, kefir and cheese the signal is neutral to mildly favourable. Pooling 18 cohorts and over 760,000 people, fermented dairy fell just short of a clear link to fewer strokes, while cheese above 25 g a day reached it — but ordinary milk carried a small protective association too and high-fat milk a small adverse one, so fermentation is not obviously what matters.[16] Blood markers of dairy fat track with about 20–35% lower rates of new type 2 diabetes, but they mainly show how much dairy fat people eat, so they prove no cause, and they cannot tell cheese from butter.[17] Cheese versus butter and the full-fat versus low-fat question are covered on Milk, yogurt and cheese.

For red meat the evidence is firmer and less flattering. In cohort data, eating red meat in place of low-fat dairy tracked with about 11% higher death rates, 13% more coronary disease and 20% more type 2 diabetes.[18] The proposed reasons: dairy delivers its fat inside a calcium-rich food that may blunt the cholesterol rise, while fatty meat delivers the same molecules along with other suspect compounds, especially when cooked at high heat. See Red and processed meat.

Seed oils and omega-6: the myth that won't die

Seed oils. The popular idea that linoleic acid — the main omega-6 fat in sunflower, safflower, soybean, canola and corn oil — drives inflammation and heart disease is not supported by the evidence. A 2025 review pooling 150 cohorts found more omega-6 in the diet linked to about 12% lower death rates, with no link either way to heart disease or to cancer overall, though one small signal of higher endometrial and ovarian cancer risk turned up and the certainty of the evidence ranged from very low to moderate.[19] Across 30 cohorts in 13 countries, people with the most linoleic acid in their blood had about 22% lower cardiovascular death rates than those with the least,[20] and in 15 controlled trials linoleic acid did not raise any measured marker of inflammation.[21]

The strongest case for seed oils is using them instead of saturated fat. In a review of 19 trials that simply raised omega-6 intake, usually in place of saturated or monounsaturated fat, it made little or no difference to deaths or cardiovascular events, at low certainty.[22]

The critiques that do hold up are about how oil is used, not the molecule:

  • Commercial deep-frying. Oil reused for hours in a commercial fryer is a different product. In 10 men, a meal cooked in fat taken from a fast-food fryer wiped out the arteries' ability to widen, while the same meal cooked in fresh fat did not.[23] The broader claim that this oil inflames you rests on animal and cell studies.
  • Ultra-processed food. Refined oils turn up alongside refined sugar, white flour and additives, and that surrounding food is the more plausible culprit. See Ultra-processed food.

The omega-6 to omega-3 ratio is not worth chasing. Across 36 trials, changing linoleic acid intake did not move blood levels of the omega-6 that inflammatory signals are built from.[24] The ratio does predict death rates, but mainly because omega-3 is protective: in a UK study of 85,425 adults, higher omega-6 on its own also went with lower death rates, and the authors' summary was "both are protective".[25] No major authority sets a ratio target.[26] If you want a better ratio, add omega-3 rather than cutting seed oils.

Omega-3: worth getting, but the aging-clock headline is oversold

Fatty fish twice a week, or a 1–1.5 g/day supplement of the marine omega-3s EPA and DHA if you don't eat fish, covers you. Doses, quality, the big heart trials and the raised risk of an irregular heartbeat (atrial fibrillation) at high doses are covered under Omega-3.

The headline result came from a three-year trial of 2,157 Europeans aged 70 and over, in which omega-3 slowed DNA-based aging clocks by roughly 3 to 4 months of "biological age".[27] But the clock analysis was done after the fact in a subset of 777 people, and all six of the trial's planned main outcomes showed no benefit; the caveats are weighed under Omega-3.

The plant omega-3 in flax, walnuts and canola (alpha-linolenic acid) has its own modest record: higher intake tracked with about 10% lower death rates overall, with a small rise in cancer deaths at the very highest intakes that did not hold up in the dose-response analysis.[28]

Olive oil: the best everyday oil, on evidence weaker than its reputation

Extra-virgin olive oil is a sound default, and its biggest benefit comes from replacing worse fats. In the Spanish PREDIMED trial of 7,447 people at high cardiovascular risk, a Mediterranean diet with extra olive oil or extra nuts cut major cardiovascular events by about 30% against a low-fat diet over nearly five years.[29] The original 2013 paper was retracted and republished in 2018 after randomisation problems were found, with roughly the same result; more on the trial under PREDIMED.

Beyond PREDIMED the evidence is observational and mostly low quality.[30] Swapping butter, margarine, mayonnaise or dairy fat for olive oil tracks with lower death rates, but olive oil shows no advantage over other vegetable oils.[31] A high-phenolic extra-virgin oil is worth seeking out, though most bottles fall short of the level behind Europe's health claim, and one small trial even saw LDL cholesterol rise slightly on a high-phenolic oil.[32]

Other oils. Canola and soybean oil sit in the sound middle, with no harm signal in cohort data. Avocado oil is another option, but it has no legal quality standard in the US, and repeated testing has found most retail samples rancid or cut with cheaper oils — 82% of bottles in 2020, some labelled "pure" or "extra virgin" almost entirely soybean oil.[33] Buy a brand you trust.

Coconut oil is not a health food. Across 16 trials, it raised LDL cholesterol by about 10.5 mg/dL (about 0.27 mmol/L) compared with non-tropical vegetable oils, with no benefit for blood sugar, inflammation or body fat.[34] The trials disagree a lot, so treat that as the middle of a wide range. The "medium-chain fat" pitch is misleading: coconut oil's main fat behaves in the body like an ordinary long-chain saturated fat.

Eggs: about one a day is fine for most healthy adults

Eggs have small effects that depend on where, and with what, they are eaten. Each extra egg a day is linked to about 8% higher cardiovascular risk in US cohorts, a borderline result in European ones, and no association in Asian ones[35] — plausibly because an American egg often comes with bacon, sausage and white toast, and a traditional Japanese one with rice, fish and vegetables.

Any added risk rises gradually, with no point where it suddenly jumps. The one clearly raised overall signal is about 20% higher cancer death rates at the highest egg intakes versus the lowest; higher overall and cardiovascular death rates showed up mainly in US cohorts.[36] The cholesterol in eggs barely moves blood lipids, because the liver makes less of its own, though the ratio of total to "good" HDL cholesterol does shift slightly in the wrong direction.[37]

The American Heart Association sets no numeric limit on dietary cholesterol; it is generally read as allowing up to one whole egg a day for healthy adults, with more caution in diabetes and in familial hypercholesterolaemia, an inherited cause of very high cholesterol.[38] In type 2 diabetes, some cohort data show a stronger link between eggs and heart disease, and in five Western general-population cohorts, an egg a day or more went with about 42% more new type 2 diabetes than less than one a week — an observational finding the authors themselves say should not yet change dietary advice.[39]

Fat and biological-age clocks: interesting, not settled

DNA-based aging clocks are where much of the longevity marketing around fats now lives, and the evidence is weak.

A US survey of 1,771 adults aged 50 and over linked more saturated fat to slightly older readings on a clock built to predict death — about 0.42 years per doubling of intake — and more polyunsaturated fat to younger readings on several clocks.[40] But it was a one-time snapshot, intake came from a single day's food recall, monounsaturated fat also tracked with an older reading, and in the authors' own larger sensitivity analysis the saturated and monounsaturated links lost significance, leaving the polyunsaturated findings the most consistent. Some of the clocks involved are older designs that perform poorly in disease settings.[41]

When diet has been tested properly, the clocks have not behaved like useful targets. In a 12-month trial randomising 144 adults to low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets, clock changes were unrelated to the diet's other health effects, and the authors urged caution about treating epigenetic age as something you can modify.[42] A two-year study found the clocks barely move within a person over the short term.[43]

A genetic study linking blood saturated fat to shorter telomeres (the protective caps on chromosomes) is weaker than it looks: the figure came only from a model adjusting the fat types against each other, while its main analysis pointed the other way.[44] The same caveat applies to its finding of longer telomeres with monounsaturated fat.

What to actually do

  • Cut industrial trans fats. If you live or shop somewhere without a ban, reading labels for "partially hydrogenated oil" is still the reliable safeguard.
  • Replace saturated fat rather than just cutting it. Keep it near 10% of calories, and swap butter and fatty red meat for vegetable oils, olive oil and nuts, not refined carbohydrates.
  • Make extra-virgin olive oil your default oil, ideally a high-phenolic one. Canola, sunflower and safflower oils are sound alternatives; if you use avocado oil, buy a reputable brand. Skip coconut oil as a "health" choice.
  • Get omega-3s from fatty fish — salmon, sardines, mackerel, herring — twice a week, or 1–1.5 g/day EPA+DHA. See Omega-3.
  • Don't fear seed oils at home. Use fresh oil at moderate heat; avoid ultra-processed food and commercial deep-fried food instead. Don't chase an omega-6 to omega-3 ratio.
  • Treat dairy and red meat differently. Fermented dairy is roughly neutral; red meat in volume is the saturated-fat source most worth limiting.
  • Eggs: up to one a day is fine for most healthy adults, ideally with vegetables and whole grains rather than bacon and white bread. If you have diabetes or familial hypercholesterolaemia, be more conservative and discuss it with your doctor.

Further reading

  • Sacks FM et al. Dietary fats and cardiovascular disease — AHA Presidential Advisory. Circulation 2017.[45]
  • Hooper L et al. Reduction in saturated fat intake for cardiovascular disease. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2020.[46]
  • Howard BV et al. Low-fat dietary pattern and risk of cardiovascular disease — WHI Dietary Modification Trial. JAMA 2006.[47]
  • Zhang Y et al. Butter and plant-based oils intake and mortality. JAMA Internal Medicine 2025.[48]
  • de Goede J et al. Dairy consumption and risk of stroke — systematic review and updated dose-response meta-analysis. JAHA 2016.[49]
  • Marklund M et al. Biomarkers of dietary omega-6 fatty acids and incident cardiovascular disease and mortality. Circulation 2019.[50]
  • Sadeghi R et al. Dietary and circulating omega-6 fatty acids and cardiovascular disease, cancer, and mortality — global meta-analysis of 150 cohorts. J Transl Med 2025.[51]
  • Bischoff-Ferrari HA et al. Individual and additive effects of vitamin D, omega-3 and exercise on DNA methylation clocks of biological aging in older adults from the DO-HEALTH trial. Nature Aging 2025.[52]
  • Estruch R et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts — PREDIMED. NEJM 2018.[53]
  • Neelakantan N et al. The effect of coconut oil consumption on cardiovascular risk factors. Circulation 2020.[54]
  • Zhao B et al. Associations of dietary cholesterol, serum cholesterol, and egg consumption with mortality — systematic review and meta-analysis. Circulation 2022.[55]
  • Mousavi SM et al. Consumption of eggs and risk of all-cause and cause-specific mortality — dose-response meta-analysis. Advances in Nutrition 2022.[56]
  • Bozack AK et al. Dietary fatty acids and epigenetic aging in US adults: results from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. npj Aging 2025.[57]

— § —