Bone density

Bones that are never loaded hard enough lose strength, and that sets up many later-life fractures. Walking does little for the spine and swimming leaves the skeleton largely untouched; heavy lifting plus jumping is the best-tested way to build bone, and exercise now has the outcome that matters most, with about a quarter fewer major fractures.

Lift heavy twice a week, add a short bout of hopping, daily if you can, and keep doing it, because in one trial the spine advantage had faded within three months of stopping. Back that up with enough protein, calcium from food first, and vitamin D if you are low. Before you start, know the two real limits — avoid rounding your back, especially under load, and if you have already had a spinal fracture or several low-trauma fractures, keep impact to about brisk-walking level — and ask whether any of your medications are costing you bone.

Why bone matters for how long you live

Low bone density predicts a shorter life, not just a broken hip, though what the link means is still unclear. Evidence rating: Moderate — large and repeated, but observational.

Across cohort after cohort, low bone mineral density goes with higher death rates from any cause, even after allowing for age, sex, body size, smoking and metabolic disease.[1] In one widely cited US study, people with osteoporosis had about 40% higher all-cause mortality than people with normal bone, while milder bone loss (osteopenia) showed no excess overall. In adults over 50 both carried more risk: osteopenia about 43% higher mortality and osteoporosis nearly three times (the paper's running text swaps the two overall figures; its table has them right).[2]

In the whole cohort, the same study tested each cause of death separately (heart disease, stroke, cancer) and none held up once other factors were accounted for. Fracture deaths were never analysed. Low bone mass seems to track something broader about cardiometabolic health, not to kill through a known route.

Losing bone and muscle together is worse. Across 14,429 adults followed over time, having both carried about 53% higher mortality than not having the combination.[3] In 572 older hospital patients, three-year mortality was 46% with both conditions against 9% with neither.[4] That is an acute-care group in their mid-seventies: read it as "the two compound each other", not as your own number. The two are linked because weak muscle stops loading bone and releases inflammatory signals that slow bone building.

Bone and arteries are coupled. As bone loses mineral, calcium tends to build up in artery walls, and inflammation from active bone loss damages blood vessels, though the review that lays this out says the causal relationship between the two systems "remains unclear".[5]

A bone-to-brain signal is a hypothesis, not a reason to train. In mice, a hormone made by bone cells (osteocalcin) reaches the brain and seems to support memory. But two labs that built mice without osteocalcin found none of the expected problems, and the review that assembles the pathway calls it "incompletely understood".[6] See Dementia prevention.

Why walking and swimming don't build bone

Bone only grows when it is loaded harder than it is used to. In the standard model, the mechanostat, bone adds mass above one strain threshold, removes it below a lower one and ignores everything in between, so a load has to be unusual in size, not just repeated often.[7] Everyday activity, however often you repeat it, does not cross that line for the spine.

Walking. Evidence rating: Moderate that it does not build spine bone. Pooling eight walking trials in postmenopausal women found no meaningful effect at the lumbar spine and a small gain at the femoral neck (the top of the thigh bone, where hips break). The trials were small and of poor quality, and the authors still recommend exercise with more targeted loading.[8]

Swimming. A review of 64 studies found competitive swimmers had bone density similar to sedentary people and lower than athletes in high-impact sports. Swimming does not seem to harm bone; the water just takes away the impact.[9] Water-based exercise classes for older adults do show a small gain at the spine and a less certain one at the hip.[10]

The American College of Sports Medicine draws the same line, recommending weight-bearing, high-impact and resistance activity rather than low-impact aerobic work for bone.[11] But "they do nothing for bone" overstates it: a 2026 analysis of 74 trials ranked mind-body exercise (such as Tai Chi or yoga) combined with resistance work as the most effective option at both spine and hip, and found aerobic and mind-body work each had some site-specific effects of their own.[12]

Vibration plates are the borderline case: recent pooled analyses find a small, low-certainty effect at the total femur only, not at the femoral neck or spine, so at best an add-on for people who cannot do impact work.[13]

What lifting trials actually show

Heavy, supervised lifting raised spine density in women who already had fragile bones, and nobody broke anything. The hip result is smaller and less consistent. Evidence rating: Strong.

The LIFTMOR trial. This Australian trial randomly assigned postmenopausal women already diagnosed with low bone mass to a gentle home programme or to supervised heavy training twice a week for 8 months: deadlifts, overhead presses and back squats at 5 sets of 5 reps above 85% of their one-rep maximum (the most weight they could lift once), plus jumping chin-ups with firm drop landings.[14] The heavy group gained about 2.9% at the spine and 0.3% at the femoral neck and improved physical function, while the gentle group lost bone. The follow-on trial from the same team found about two-thirds of that spine gain (1.9% against 0.1% on the gentle programme) and no advantage at the total hip.[15]

Safety. LIFTMOR reported one adverse event, a minor back spasm, in supervised women screened for conditions and medications that affect bone, who built up to the heavy loads gradually; the follow-on trial reported seven adverse events across its groups and called both programmes well tolerated. Neither trial had a fragility fracture.

Fractures, not just density. Density is a stand-in for the real outcome, a broken bone. Pooling eleven controlled exercise trials, covering nearly 20,000 participant-years, exercise cut major osteoporotic fractures by about a quarter, with very consistent results across studies.[16] But programmes that increased intensity over time showed no significant advantage, and neither did programmes lasting longer than a year, so the fracture benefit does not clearly back the "heavy or nothing" message that the density trials support.

How heavy is heavy enough? The 2026 American College of Sports Medicine resistance-training position stand (not bone-specific) says the biggest gain comes from going from none to any, training all major muscle groups at least twice a week at around 80% of maximum for strength.[17] For bone, pooled trials defined "heavy" as 70% of your maximum or more, and that helped at the hip but not at the spine; three sessions a week was the best-supported frequency.[18] A 2026 synthesis that compared heavy and lighter loading head-to-head in adults over 50 found no significant bone difference at either site (the spine result was borderline), even though strength clearly favoured heavy; adverse events and falls did not differ significantly, though both estimates leaned toward more with heavy loading and were very imprecise.[19] So heavy loading is the best-evidenced route to the hip, but lighter loading is not useless for bone.

How to dose it: hard, brief, often, and for good

Bone responds to sharp, heavy loads, gets bored within a few repetitions, only strengthens where it is loaded, and loses its gains quickly when you stop. Evidence rating: Moderate — these rules are well replicated in animals and in natural experiments, but the exact human thresholds are extrapolated.

Impact seems to need to be daily. Sharp, fast landings deliver the largest loads: two-footed jumps with a bounce straight back up reach about four to five times body weight.[20] Yet in the one trial that tested how often to hop, gentler one-legged hops (50 a session, in healthy premenopausal women) did nothing for femoral-neck density on two days a week; only the daily group gained, at about 1.8%.[21] A year of daily hopping raised femoral-neck density in older men,[22] and six months of hopping did the same in postmenopausal women, with no sign of harm on knee-cartilage scans.[23]

Little and often beats one long session. Bone cells stop responding after a few loading cycles. In rodents, splitting the daily load into several short bouts gave a much bigger response,[24] and about 8 hours between bouts was enough to restore full sensitivity.[25] Short bouts across the day add to the twice-weekly heavy session; they don't replace it.

Bone only builds where it is loaded. In 105 national-level female tennis and squash players, the playing arm had roughly 9% to 16% more bone mineral than the other arm, against 3–5% in non-players, and up to 23% at the upper arm in those who started before their first period.[26] Pick movements that load the hip and spine.

Stop and it goes. In one trial of early-postmenopausal women with low bone mass, the spine advantage from training was lost after just 3 months off, even though strength lasted longer.[27]

Long sitting: contested. Evidence rating: Weak. A review from the International Osteoporosis Foundation's rehabilitation group argues that long sedentary time harms bone regardless of training, while calling that evidence emerging.[28] In a Canadian cohort of more than 8,000 adults followed for a decade, sedentary time did not predict bone loss or fracture once activity was accounted for.[29] Replacing sitting with walking does track with lower osteoporosis risk — a reason to move, not to fear the chair. See Sitting.

Who should be careful

Supervised heavy loading is not the risk; a few specific movements, existing spinal fractures and several common drugs are.

Two exercise exclusions. A UK expert consensus advises avoiding postures that round the back a lot, in exercise or daily life and especially under load (not the neutral-spine hinge of a deadlift). If you have already had a vertebral fracture or several low-trauma fractures, it advises usually keeping impact to about the level of brisk walking.[30] Many vertebral fractures cause no symptoms, so "my back doesn't hurt" does not mean your spine is intact.

Medications that cost bone. Several common long-term drugs speed bone loss. Don't stop them on your own, but ask for a scan and a conversation. Steroids (glucocorticoids) are the most potent. Proton-pump inhibitors (acid blockers such as omeprazole) carried about 30% higher hip-fracture risk in pooled observational studies, whether use was short or long.[31] SSRI antidepressants, aromatase inhibitors and androgen-deprivation therapy belong on the list too. Ask your prescriber about the lowest effective dose and about stopping acid blockers you don't need.

Testosterone is not a fracture treatment. It can raise spine density in older men with low testosterone, but the large fracture trial found the opposite of protection: 3.5% of men on testosterone had a fracture over about three years against 2.5% on placebo, roughly one extra fracture per hundred men treated.[32] Those men had low testosterone plus high cardiovascular risk, so the figure does not transfer directly to a healthy midlife man; still, a density gain is not an anti-fracture claim. See Testosterone therapy.

Rapid weight loss. Fast weight loss, including on GLP-1 drugs, lowers bone density, especially at the hip. In the one trial that separated the parts, exercise plus liraglutide kept hip and spine density no worse than placebo over a year, while the drug alone lost more bone than exercise alone.[33] Whether that is lost loading or a direct drug effect is not settled, partly because the groups did not lose the same amount of weight. Evidence rating: Moderate. Either way, train, eat enough protein, and get enough calcium and vitamin D while you lose weight.

Other harms to know. High intake of preformed vitamin A is linked to higher hip-fracture risk (below). Don't add vitamin K2 supplements if you take warfarin without talking to your prescriber. Smoking and heavy drinking are directly toxic to bone, and alcohol also raises fall risk. Shift workers carry a bone-loss risk that is hard to fully offset.

Hormones and the timing of bone loss

For women, the years around menopause are when bone goes fastest. Men are badly under-served by bone care.

The perimenopausal window. Evidence rating: Strong. The fastest loss runs from about a year before the final period to two years after. In that window women lose about 7% of spine bone, most of the 10.6% lost across the whole decade.[34]

Hormone therapy prevents fractures, but it is not a bone-only drug. In the largest randomised trial, 8.6% of women on oestrogen plus progestin had a fracture over 5.6 years against 11.1% on placebo, about 2.5 fewer per hundred women, at every age. In that trial, other risks cancelled out the fracture benefit overall, even in women at high fracture risk, so it is not usually started for bone alone.[35] Protection fades after you stop — fracture risk climbs back over the decade that follows.[36] The Menopause Society supports it for preventing bone loss and fracture in suitable women; it is an individual decision with a clinician. See Menopausal hormone therapy.

Men. At age 80, excess death in the year after a hip fracture is about 8% in women and 18% in men.[37] In men it is oestrogen, made from testosterone, that mainly holds back bone breakdown: in experiments that switched off men's sex hormones, bone breakdown rose much more when conversion to oestrogen was also blocked.[38] Evidence rating: Moderate. The Endocrine Society advises screening all men 70 and over, and men 50–69 with risk factors.

Protein, calcium and the supplements

Food supports bone but cannot replace loading, and most supplement claims are weaker than they sound.

Protein doesn't harm bone, and you need enough. Evidence rating: Moderate. The old worry that protein "leaches calcium from bones" has never been shown. The umbrella review behind the German nutrition guideline rated the evidence insufficient on almost every bone outcome — with a possible 11% lower hip-fracture risk at higher intake, and possibly no effect on total bone density.[39] Bone matrix is built from protein, so you need enough: the site's working range is in the action list, and Protein has the expert-group targets for older adults.

Calcium: food first, and the form matters. Dairy, kale and bok choy deliver calcium your body can use; spinach does not, because its oxalate binds most of it. If you supplement to reach 1,000–1,200 mg a day in total, cover only the gap your diet leaves, never as a large single dose.[40] Calcium carbonate is cheapest but needs stomach acid, so take it with food; it often causes constipation and bloating. Calcium citrate is absorbed without stomach acid,[41] the simplest choice for older adults and anyone on acid-reducing medication or with reflux; carbonate taken with a meal also works. Taking it with the evening meal is a harmless bet, since bone breakdown peaks at night, and one small two-week study found an evening dose cut bone-breakdown markers where a morning dose did not. Calcium has the absorption and timing studies.

Vitamin D: correct a deficiency, don't top up. Evidence rating: Strong. A trial of 25,871 adults who mostly had enough vitamin D found 2,000 IU a day did not reduce fractures, including in those with low bone density or taking calcium.[42] See Vitamin D.

Vitamin K2: good story, no fracture proof. K2 activates the proteins that put calcium into bone and keep it out of arteries, and supplements do shift those markers, but that review measured no bone-density or fracture outcomes.[43] The Japanese fracture trials of the high-dose form (MK-4) came from a literature with many retracted papers,[44] and the one large trial free of those integrity concerns missed its main goal and had more adverse events on the drug.[45] For most healthy adults the practical choice is MK-7 (dose in the action list); Vitamin K2 has the full evidence, including the retractions.

Too much vitamin A is a harm. Evidence rating: Moderate. Across 283,930 people, high intake of preformed vitamin A (retinol) went with about 40% higher hip-fracture risk; beta-carotene did not.[46] Avoid high-dose retinol supplements, large amounts of liver and cod-liver-oil megadosing.

Prunes. Evidence rating: Moderate. In a 12-month trial of 235 postmenopausal women, 50 g a day (about 4–6 prunes) kept hip density steady while controls lost about 1%. The 100 g dose showed no significant hip benefit, and 41% of that group dropped out.[47]

Collagen peptides. Evidence rating: Weak. 5 g a day for a year raised spine and femoral-neck density in one trial of 131 postmenopausal women with low bone density. Several such trials are industry-linked.[48]

Magnesium (200–400 mg a day of elemental magnesium, food first) helps activate vitamin D. Higher intake tracks with marginally higher density but shows no fracture benefit at all — the pooled hip-fracture estimate even leaned toward higher risk, though too imprecisely to mean much. See Magnesium. The "acid-ash diet leaches calcium" idea is plausible on paper but not established.

When a normal scan isn't the whole story

A standard bone scan (DXA, a low-dose X-ray that measures mineral) shows how much bone you have, not how well it is built.

Who needs a scan. Looking at adults 40 and over, the 2025 US Preventive Services Task Force recommends screening only for women 65 and older, and for younger postmenopausal women whose fracture risk is increased on a formal risk tool such as FRAX. For men it found the evidence insufficient either way.[49] Ask for an earlier scan if you have a reason such as steroid use, an eating-disorder history, premature menopause, a parent who broke a hip, chronic kidney disease, or a low-trauma fracture already. A baseline scan in your late 40s is a personal choice, not standard care.

The Trabecular Bone Score. Evidence rating: Moderate. Read from the same spine scan, this score reflects the inner structure of bone. In 2,641 US adults aged 60 and over followed for nearly twelve years, those with the lowest scores had about 47% higher all-cause mortality and roughly double the cancer mortality, even after allowing for bone density.[50] It is worth asking for on a spine scan you are having anyway, but it should not decide treatment on its own, and tracking it over time is unlikely to help.[51]

Type 2 diabetes. In women with long-standing type 2 diabetes, bone material strength measured directly was about 10% lower than in matched controls with the same density, so the weakness was invisible on the scan.[52] A "normal" scan in someone with long-standing diabetes is less reassuring than it looks. See Metabolic flexibility.

Cortisol and stress. Evidence rating: Moderate. Steroid drugs damage bone badly. Mild excess cortisol made by the body goes with worse bone quality even at normal density: 75 such patients had the same density as matched controls but lower bone-quality scores.[53] In mice, blocking a protein that drives steroid-related bone loss prevented the loss.[54] A genetic study hints that muscle loss lies partly on the path from cortisol to osteoporosis, but it rests on three gene variants and gives mixed results by site.[55] See Stress.

What to actually do

  1. Lift heavy, twice a week. Squat, hinge, press and pull at around 70–85% of your maximum, 5–8 reps, supervised at first. See Resistance training.
  2. Hop daily, and keep going. About 50 one-legged hops in different directions. Other jumps have not been tested at the hip the way hopping has, and squat-type jumps may load the hip less than walking. If you have had a vertebral fracture or several low-trauma fractures, read Who should be careful first.
  3. Move through the day. Something like 7,000 steps and an hourly break from sitting. The step evidence is about mortality, not bone, but steps give your skeleton low-level loading a gym session does not.
  4. Train balance. Most hip fractures — around nine in ten — follow a fall. Tai Chi cuts the number of people who fall by about a quarter.[56] See Mobility and balance.
  5. Protein 1.2–1.6 g/kg a day for an active midlife adult (1.6–2.0 if older and training hard, cutting calories or recovering from acute illness or surgery; on a GLP-1 drug, 1.2–1.6 g/kg or an absolute 80–120 g, avoiding sustained intake at 2 g/kg or more), spread over three or four meals of about 30–40 g. If you have severe kidney disease and are not on dialysis, ask your doctor before raising protein at all.
  6. Calcium 1,000–1,200 mg a day, mostly from food, supplements only for the gap (which form).
  7. Keep vitamin D at a blood level of roughly 50–125 nmol/L (20–50 ng/mL), supplementing if you are below it, plus vitamin K2 (MK-7) at about 90–180 µg a day with D3; magnesium from food first.
  8. Sleep close to 8 hours, don't smoke, and keep alcohol low. Bone breakdown follows a daily body clock, and shift work is a flagged risk.

What's overrated or not ready

  • "Walking is enough for bones." Not for the spine (good for your heart).
  • "Calcium and vitamin D will protect my skeleton." Necessary, not sufficient. Without loading, bone has no signal to build.
  • "Heavy lifting will break fragile bones." Not under supervision (see Who should be careful for the two exclusions).
  • Bone-health supplement stacks. Many blends are underdosed on K2, overdosed on calcium, or built around evidence-light ingredients such as strontium citrate.
  • Probiotics. In women aged 75 to 80, a year of Lactobacillus reuteri only slightly slowed bone loss, with both groups still losing.[57] A larger two-year trial of the same strain in 239 early-postmenopausal women found no effect on any bone outcome.[58] The broader gut-bone link is mostly animal and lab work; a fibre-rich, varied diet is worth eating anyway.[59] See Fermented foods.
  • Training at a particular time of day. Made no difference in human studies; train when you will actually do it.[60] See Circadian rhythms.
  • New bone drugs. A receptor that senses loading, a brain hormone that protects bone during breastfeeding, and a federal joint-repair programme are all promising, and all in animals or early stages.[61][62][63] Don't wait for them; loading and nutrition are the floor any future drug will be added to.

Further reading

  • Watson SL et al. High-Intensity Resistance and Impact Training Improves Bone Mineral Density and Physical Function in Postmenopausal Women With Osteopenia and Osteoporosis: The LIFTMOR Randomized Controlled Trial. J Bone Miner Res 2018.[64]
  • Kistler-Fischbacher M et al. A Comparison of Bone-Targeted Exercise With and Without Antiresorptive Bone Medication to Reduce Indices of Fracture Risk in Postmenopausal Women With Low Bone Mass: The MEDEX-OP Randomized Controlled Trial. J Bone Miner Res 2021.[65]
  • Hoffmann I et al. Exercise and the prevention of major osteoporotic fractures in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis with special emphasis on intensity progression and study duration. Osteoporos Int 2023.[66]
  • Zhao F et al. Optimal resistance training parameters for improving bone mineral density in postmenopausal women: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg Res 2025.[67]
  • Martyn-St James M, Carroll S. Meta-analysis of walking for preservation of bone mineral density in postmenopausal women. Bone 2008.[68]
  • Brooke-Wavell K et al. Strong, steady and straight: UK consensus statement on physical activity and exercise for osteoporosis. Br J Sports Med 2022.[69]
  • Kemmler W et al. Detraining Effects on Musculoskeletal Parameters in Early Postmenopausal Osteopenic Women: 3-Month Follow-Up of the Randomized Controlled ACTLIFE Study. Calcif Tissue Int 2021.[70]
  • Nicholson WK et al. Screening for Osteoporosis to Prevent Fractures: US Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation Statement. JAMA 2025.[71]
  • Shi L et al. The associations between bone mineral density and long-term risks of cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all-cause mortality. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne) 2022.[72]
  • LeBoff MS et al. Supplemental Vitamin D and Incident Fractures in Midlife and Older Adults. N Engl J Med 2022.[73]
  • Wu AM et al. The relationship between vitamin A and risk of fracture: meta-analysis of prospective studies. J Bone Miner Res 2014.[74]
  • Snyder PJ et al. Testosterone Treatment and Fractures in Men with Hypogonadism. N Engl J Med 2024.[75]
  • Kannus P et al. Effect of starting age of physical activity on bone mass in the dominant arm of tennis and squash players. Ann Intern Med 1995.[76]

— § —